id,proposition,classification,confidence_percent,novelty_percent,potential_impact_percent,experimental_difficulty_percent,evidence,limitations,manuscript_section C01,Exact six-state moving-frame factorization,B/model theorem,98,55,70,80,Proved algebraically in the declared finite-dimensional model; numerical residual 2.57e-9 or below.,Specific coherent recovery jumps and compensating controls are assumed; no chemistry implementation.,5 C02,Full tangent correctability implies scalar local curvature,B/model theorem,98,40,65,60,Knill–Laflamme tangent Gram condition yields scalar curvature.,"Exact correction of full tangent span by one recovery, local contractible-loop setting; not a general no-go for encoded holonomic computation.",5 C03,Isospectral-base pair-tag addressing,B/model construction,99,50,60,65,Three-tag retargeting and q=6 pair construction checked.,Tags have physically different couplings; compensating Hamiltonians need not remain isospectral.,5 C04,Population-return recovery can damage logical holonomy,B/executed model,99,35,60,55,Initial and matched smooth ablations retain this failure.,Not a theorem that every dissipative implementation is inferior.,20 C05,Corrected recovery outperforms matched coherent control,Failed in tested model,2,0,0,0,No supporting result: coherent selectivity 2188.6 versus corrected recovery 774.5.,Other noise models or resource constraints remain untested; these scores apply to the present evidence.,20 C06,Useful chemical recovery and commit interface,C/unvalidated hypothesis,35,65,85,95,"Specified operator and experimental contract, not fabricated.","Molecular observability, physical reservoir engineering and energy cost remain unproved.",21 C07,Restricted logical chemistry demonstration,C/unvalidated hypothesis,70,45,85,80,Two-route-plus-third-route protocol and exact hypothetical CTMC supplied.,No chemical rates fitted or measured; no universal chemistry claim.,19 C08,Exact commit-race error probability,B/model theorem,99,30,65,45,Analytic formula checked against transient generator and matrix exponential.,Four-state rate assumptions; no hidden irreversible channels.,11 C09,Conditional compositional construction,B/conditional proposition,99,20,70,80,Union-bound and contract-preservation argument.,"Reachable validated decomposition is a premise, not established for arbitrary matter.",9 C10,Trillion-port joint closure of all six bottlenecks,D/speculative moonshot,10,60,100,100,Only scenario bounds and stop/go conditions.,"No trillion-port controller, metrology, feedstock, or thermal integration.",16 C11,Heterogeneous factory more plausible than one universal chemistry,C/architecture assessment,90,20,90,95,Material-family and environmental incompatibilities explicitly decomposed.,Not proof of universal coverage or a minimum number of regimes.,22 C12,Repeated checks give unlimited multiplicative selectivity,Failed beyond model floors,1,0,0,0,Persistent aliases and reaction background bound selectivity.,Conditional independent-readout suppression applies only above those floors.,17